Last Thursday evening, I was rushing home with Alex from soccer practice, and he asked if we could have a fun dessert after dinner. It reminded me of the Nutter Butter Turkey Cookies we made last Thanksgiving—and how much Alex and Sarah loved them. These cute and delicious cookies are so easy to make that we can whip them up even on weeknights. Jess from down the hall calls these her lifesaver treats, and I must agree! They're perfect for when you want to share a bit of holiday cheer with the family without spending hours in the kitchen.
Jump to:
You might also enjoy our Gluten-Free Lemon Crinkle Cookies.
Why you'll love this recipe
These Nutter Butter Turkey Cookies are sweet, fun, and kid-approved. They take just 20 minutes to prepare, making them ideal for busy families. Plus, they bring smiles every time, connecting us over the laughter and crunch of each bite.
Ingredients
- 20 medium candy eyeballs
- 10 orange m&m’s
- 6 oz. chocolate candy melts
- ⅓ cup red candy melts
- 10 nutter butters
Step-by-step instructions
- Melt both the chocolate and the red candy melts as directed on the bag.
- Dip half of the nutter butter into the chocolate candy melts. Place on parchment or freezer paper shiny side up.
- Add the two eyes to the top of each nutter butter. Add the orange m&m’s for the nose area to all the nutter butters. Let dry.
- With a pastry brush, add a good dab of red candy melts next to the nose. Let dry and serve!
Recipe tips & variations
- If you're short on time, use yellow m&m's instead of red candy melts for the wattle.
- Try different colors of m&m’s to match different festive occasions, making these cookies versatile for any celebration.
Storage & reheating
Once prepared, store these cookies in an airtight container. They’ll stay fresh for up to a week, but I doubt they'll last that long with kids around!
FAQs
How do you make Nutter Butter turkey cookies without them falling apart?
To ensure your cookies don't fall apart, make sure the candy melts have cooled slightly before you start dipping. This makes them easier to handle.
Can I use different candy melts or substitutions for this recipe?
Absolutely! White chocolate or even butterscotch chips melted can create a fun taste twist.
How long do Nutter Butter turkey cookies stay fresh after making them?
Stored in an airtight container, they'll stay fresh for about a week.
What’s the best way to store these turkey cookies before serving?
Keep them in a cool, dry place—away from the little hands reaching for them before dinner!
Recipes you may like
For more sweet treats, check out our Creamy Mango Banana Smoothie for a Fresh Morning Boost or our refreshing Pineapple Green Smoothie.
Print
Nutter Butter Turkey Cookies
- Total Time: 20 minutes
- Yield: 10 cookies 1x
- Diet: Vegetarian
Description
Delicious and fun Nutter Butter Turkey Cookies that are kid-approved and perfect for sharing holiday cheer.
Ingredients
- 20 medium candy eyeballs
- 10 orange m&m’s
- 6 oz. chocolate candy melts
- ⅓ cup red candy melts
- 10 nutter butters
Instructions
- Melt both the chocolate and the red candy melts as directed on the bag.
- Dip half of the nutter butter into the chocolate candy melts. Place on parchment or freezer paper shiny side up.
- Add the two eyes to the top of each nutter butter. Add the orange m&m’s for the nose area to all the nutter butters. Let dry.
- With a pastry brush, add a good dab of red candy melts next to the nose. Let dry and serve!
Notes
- If you're short on time, use yellow m&m's instead of red candy melts for the wattle.
- Try different colors of m&m’s to match different festive occasions, making these cookies versatile for any celebration.
- Prep Time: 20 minutes
- Category: Dessert
- Method: No-bake
- Cuisine: American
Nutrition
- Serving Size: 1 cookie
