Leftover Pasta Frittata

There is half a bowl of spaghetti sitting in my fridge right now, and I already know exactly what is happening to it tomorrow morning. This leftover pasta frittata is the reason I stopped throwing away cold noodles years ago.

Jump to:

• Why You Will Like This Recipe
• Ingredients For This Leftover Pasta Frittata
• Leftover Pasta Frittata
• How To Make A Leftover Pasta Frittata
• Storage And Reheating
• Variations Worth Trying With Pasta Frittata
• Leftover Pasta Frittata FAQ
• Recipes You May Like
• Conclusion

I learned it from my mom when I was about fifteen. She never called it a recipe. She would crack eggs into a bowl, dump in whatever pasta was left from Sunday, add a fistful of cheese, and slide the whole thing into a skillet like it was nothing.

Honestly? I thought it sounded strange back then. Cold spaghetti and eggs did not seem like a real meal to me. Then I tasted it, and I understood why she made it almost every week.

Now I make it in my own Manhattan kitchen, usually on a Tuesday when I open the fridge and see three containers of pasta and no plan. Alex calls it pasta pie. Sarah picks out the crispy edges before I even get it to the table.

Here is what you can expect. You get a golden, cheesy skillet meal that comes together in about 30 minutes, works with any pasta shape, and tastes like you actually cooked something. It slices like a pie, holds up in a lunchbox, and feeds four people from ingredients you already own.

If you like the idea of dinners that use one pan and very little effort, my creamy one pot pasta is the recipe that usually creates the leftovers I turn into this frittata the next day. The two go together in my house more often than I want to admit.

Why You Will Like This Recipe

• Ready in 30 minutes from the moment you crack the first egg
• Works with any leftover pasta, sauced or plain, long or short
• Uses pantry basics like eggs, cheese, and a little cream
• Crispy golden edges with a soft, cheesy middle
• Slices cleanly, so it works hot for dinner or cold for lunch the next day
• Kids can help mix everything, which mine always want to do

Ingredients For This Leftover Pasta Frittata

Six eggs are the base here, and the pasta does the rest of the work. Nothing on this list is hard to find.

• 1 pound leftover pasta (any shape, sauced or plain)
• 6 eggs
• ½ cup hard cheese, grated, such as parmesan or cheddar
• ⅓ cup melting cheese, grated, such as mozzarella
• 3 to 4 tablespoons cream
• 2 tablespoons fresh parsley, chopped
• Salt and pepper
• 1 to 2 tablespoons butter or olive oil

A few notes from my kitchen. Whole milk works if you have no cream, though the middle turns out a little less soft.

Any cheese you love is fine here. I have used goat cheese, provolone, and once a sad half block of gouda that needed a purpose.

Cold pasta straight from the fridge is actually better than warm pasta. It holds its shape and does not turn mushy in the eggs.

Print

How To Make A Leftover Pasta Frittata

Get The Oven And Skillet Ready

Heat your oven to 350ºF (180ºC). Pull out a cast iron skillet, or any oven safe pan you own.

Set it aside for now. You want the oven fully heated before the eggs hit the stove.

Mix The Eggs And Cheese

In a large bowl, whisk the eggs with the cream, salt, and pepper. Do not beat them hard. You want them mixed, not fluffy, so the frittata stays flat instead of puffing up and sinking.

Add the pasta, half of the hard cheese, and all of the melting cheese. Stir until every noodle is coated.

Taste and season again. Here is the thing, leftover pasta is already seasoned, but you just added eggs and cream that need salt of their own.

Cook It On The Stove First

Melt the butter or oil in the skillet over low heat. Pour in the pasta and egg mixture and spread it flat.

Now leave it alone for 8 to 10 minutes. No stirring, no poking. The bottom sets into a golden crust while the middle stays wet, and that is exactly right.

Scatter the rest of the hard cheese over the top.

Finish It In The Oven

Move the skillet to the middle rack and bake for 7 to 8 minutes, until the center is almost firm. A slight wobble is fine.

Switch the oven to broil at 400ºF (200ºC) and give it about 5 more minutes. Watch it closely, because the top goes from golden to too dark quickly.

Take the pan out with thick oven mitts. That handle stays screaming hot, and I learned that the hard way in my twenties. Sprinkle the parsley on top and let it rest 5 minutes before slicing.

Storage And Reheating

Let the frittata cool completely before it goes anywhere. Warm eggs in a sealed container turn watery.

Slice it, then store the pieces in an airtight glass container in the fridge for up to 3 days. I stack them with a paper towel in between to catch moisture.

To reheat, use a dry skillet over medium low heat for about 3 minutes per side. The edges crisp up again, which the microwave will never do for you.

You can freeze slices too. Wrap each one in parchment, then foil, and use them within a month.

One thing I noticed after making this for years is that day two tastes better. The cheese settles and the seasoning spreads through the whole slice.

Variations Worth Trying With Pasta Frittata

• Use pasta with red sauce. Leftover bolognese makes a deeply savory version that Donald asks for by name.
• Stir in chopped ham, cooked bacon, or sausage that needs using up.
• Add sautéed spinach, roasted peppers, or leftover broccoli for something green.
• Bake it in single serving ramekins for lunchboxes.
• Swap the parsley for basil or chives.

What if your pasta is already loaded with sauce? Cut the cream back to 2 tablespoons so the middle still sets properly.

A word of warning from experience. I once used a nonstick pan with a plastic handle and nearly melted it under the broiler. Check your pan before it goes in the oven.

Leftover Pasta Frittata FAQ

Can you make a frittata with leftover pasta?

Yes, and it is honestly the best use for it. Cold pasta soaks up the egg mixture and holds its shape while it bakes, which gives you clean slices instead of scrambled eggs with noodles in them.

What types of pasta work best in a pasta frittata?

Long strands like spaghetti and linguine tangle together and hold the slice beautifully. Short shapes like penne and rigatoni work too, and they trap little pockets of cheese. I have used both many times with good results.

Can leftover pasta frittata be made without cream?

Absolutely. Whole milk is my first swap, and it changes very little. You can also skip the dairy entirely, though the texture turns firmer and more like a baked omelet.

How do you know when a pasta frittata is fully cooked?

Press the center gently with the back of a spoon. It should feel set with just a slight give, and no liquid egg should pool around your spoon. The top will look golden and the edges will pull away from the pan.

Recipes You May Like

• Easy Sausage Quiche is another egg and cheese bake that feeds a crowd on a slow weekend morning.
• Crispy Home Fries are what I serve on the side when the frittata is dinner instead of breakfast.
• Italian Creamy Sausage Pasta gives you a rich pasta dinner tonight and the leftovers for this frittata tomorrow.

Conclusion

So here is the short version. Mix cold pasta with eggs, cream, and cheese, cook it low and slow in a skillet, then finish it in the oven until the top turns golden.

I love this one because it costs almost nothing and still feels like a real meal. My mom made it for the same reason.

Give it a try the next time you stare at a container of noodles and feel guilty about it. Then tell me how it went, because I read every comment.

Save this leftover pasta frittata to your Pinterest board so it is waiting for you on the night you need it.